ironfern @ docs ~/math/grade-9/4-inequalities/proof-methods $

Proof Methods for Inequalities

Knowing that an inequality is true is useful, but knowing why it is true — and being able to prove it — is at the heart of mathematics. In this lesson we study four standard methods for proving inequalities.

Method 1: Direct Transformation

Theorem — Direct Transformation

Transform the inequality step-by-step using equivalent operations until you reach a statement that is obviously true (or obviously false). Key rules:

  • Adding the same value to both sides preserves the inequality.
  • Multiplying both sides by a positive constant preserves the inequality.
  • Multiplying both sides by a negative constant reverses the inequality.
  • If a>b>0a > b > 0 and c>d>0c > d > 0, then ac>bdac > bd.
Example — AM-GM for Two Variables (Direct Proof)

Prove that a2+b22ab\dfrac{a^2 + b^2}{2} \geq ab for all real numbers a,ba, b.

Proof. Consider the difference:

a2+b22ab=(ab)20a^2 + b^2 - 2ab = (a - b)^2 \geq 0

Since (ab)2(a - b)^2 is a perfect square, it is always non-negative. Therefore a2+b22aba^2 + b^2 \geq 2ab, and dividing both sides by 22 gives:

a2+b22ab\frac{a^2 + b^2}{2} \geq ab \quad \square

Method 2: Adding a Non-Negative Quantity

Theorem — Non-Negative Difference

To prove ABA \geq B, show that ABA - B can be written as a sum of squares or another expression that is clearly 0\geq 0.

Example — Fourth Powers

Prove that a4+b4a2b2+a2b2a^4 + b^4 \geq a^2 b^2 + a^2 b^2 for all real a,ba, b.

Proof. Compute the difference:

a4+b42a2b2=(a2b2)20a^4 + b^4 - 2a^2 b^2 = (a^2 - b^2)^2 \geq 0

Since (a2b2)20(a^2 - b^2)^2 \geq 0, we have a4+b42a2b2a^4 + b^4 \geq 2a^2 b^2. \square

Method 3: Proof by Contradiction

Theorem — Proof by Contradiction

To prove statement PP, assume ¬P\neg P (the opposite). Derive a logical contradiction. Since the assumption leads to an impossibility, PP must be true.

Example — At Least One Is Greater Than 1

Prove that if a+b>2a + b > 2, then a>1a > 1 or b>1b > 1.

Proof. Assume for contradiction that both a1a \leq 1 and b1b \leq 1. Then:

a+b1+1=2a + b \leq 1 + 1 = 2

This contradicts the hypothesis a+b>2a + b > 2. Therefore at least one of a,ba, b must be greater than 11. \square

Method 4: Casewise Proof

Theorem — Casewise (Case-by-Case) Proof

Divide the problem into exhaustive cases. Prove the inequality holds in each case separately. The union of all cases covers every possibility.

Example — Triangle Inequality

Prove that a+ba+b|a + b| \leq |a| + |b| for all real a,ba, b.

Proof. We consider cases based on the signs of aa and bb.

Case 1: a0a \geq 0 and b0b \geq 0. Then a+b=a+b=a+b|a+b| = a+b = |a|+|b|. The inequality holds with equality.

Case 2: a<0a < 0 and b<0b < 0. Then a+b=(a+b)=(a)+(b)=a+b|a+b| = -(a+b) = (-a)+(-b) = |a|+|b|. Equality again.

Case 3: Mixed signs (say a0a \geq 0, b<0b < 0; the other sub-case is symmetric). Then a+bmax(a,b)a+b|a+b| \leq \max(|a|, |b|) \leq |a| + |b|, since the remaining term is non-negative.

In every case, a+ba+b|a + b| \leq |a| + |b|. \square

Rules for Inequality Operations

Note — Valid Inequality Operations
OperationValid when…
Add cc to both sidesAlways
Multiply by c>0c > 0Always (direction preserved)
Multiply by c<0c < 0Reverse the inequality sign
Square both sidesBoth sides are non-negative
Take reciprocalBoth sides have the same sign (reverses direction)

Practice

Exercise — Prove the AM-GM Inequality

Prove that aba+b2\sqrt{ab} \leq \dfrac{a + b}{2} for all a,b0a, b \geq 0.

Hint: Start by squaring both sides (valid since both sides are non-negative) and rearrange.